Satisfying a sweet craving or treating both kids and adults is a joyous task. Embracing the universally adored combo of Oreos and ice cream, these two-ingredient ice cream sandwiches redefine simplicity with charm and deliciousness.
Beginning with Oreos
Oreos play the role of “bread” here, offering a delightful balance of flavors. Their subtle sweetness complements various ice cream flavors, creating a perfect texture contrast for the ultimate treat. Whether it’s classic chocolate or the beloved Golden Oreos, both work wonders in this recipe.
Quality ice cream truly elevates the experience. While personal preferences dictate flavor choices, premium ice cream works best due to its density and slow-melting nature. Chocolate Oreos pair beautifully with mint chocolate chip, black raspberry, or coffee flavors, while Golden Oreos harmonize with lighter, fruity notes like strawberry, peaches and cream, or pistachio.
Assembling these delights is simple, yet a clever trick ensures a perfect ratio of ice cream to cookie in every bite. Mold the ice cream into a parchment tube, freezing it to create neat, sliceable discs. This method ensures uniform, flat ice cream slices ready to partner with their cookie halves.
These delectable ice cream sandwiches tend to disappear quickly, but if you manage to save some, storing them in an airtight container preserves their texture. Letting the cookies soften slightly overnight in the freezer (about 12 hours) yields a tender yet crunchy delight. The longer they sit, the softer the cookies become, offering varied textures for different preferences.